Skip to main content
Shlomi Vaknin & Co. Law Firm
An empty living room in an old apartment with sealed moving boxes on a terrazzo floor and a bunch of keys on the windowsill, and through the window a crane and the frame of a new residential building

Pinui Binui Taxation: Capital Gains Tax, Purchase Tax and VAT for Apartment Owners

Published:

Do Apartment Owners Pay Tax in Pinui Binui?

The taxation of Pinui Binui (evacuation and reconstruction) for apartment owners is built on exemptions. An owner who sells all of their rights in an apartment in the compound to the developer, and receives one replacement apartment in return, is exempt from capital gains tax (Mas Shevach) as long as the value of the new apartment does not exceed the value cap set in Section 49KB of the Real Estate Taxation Law. The owner is also exempt from purchase tax on the new apartment (Section 49KD), and the construction services they receive are subject to zero-rate VAT up to that same cap. Cash paid in addition to the apartment, or an apartment whose value exceeds the cap, creates a taxable portion.

Get an Initial Legal Consultation

Leave your details and one of our attorneys will get back to you today.

What Does the Law Say About Apartment Owners?

The law treats Pinui Binui as a sale: you sell the old apartment and its building rights to the developer, and receive a new apartment as consideration. The benefits for apartment owners are set out in Chapter Five-4 of the Real Estate Taxation Law and in Section 31A of the VAT Law. A comparison with combination transactions and TAMA 38 is available on the page Taxation of Combination Transactions, Pinui Binui and TAMA 38.

Capital Gains Tax: The Exemption and the Value Cap

The exemption applies when the apartment owner has sold all of their rights in the residential unit to the developer, and the consideration is a right in one replacement residential unit (Section 49KB(a)(1)). The value cap is the highest of three alternatives:

  • 150% of the value of the apartment sold, less the value of its additional building rights.

  • The value of a 120 sqm apartment in the same compound.

  • The value of an apartment in the same compound whose area is 150% of the area of the apartment sold, up to a maximum of 200 sqm.

On top of this cap, the law adds payment for rent during the construction period and for covering related expenses as determined by the Director. An owner of several apartments in the compound is entitled to the exemption for each one, provided that their share of rights in the replacement apartment equals their share of rights in the apartment they sold (Section 49KB(b)).

Purchase Tax

An apartment owner who sold under Section 49KB is exempt from purchase tax on the acquisition of the replacement apartment (Section 49KD). Since Amendment 96, which took effect on November 18, 2021, the right to the replacement apartment is considered a "residential apartment" for purchase tax and capital gains tax purposes, even before construction is completed (Section 49KZ1).

VAT

The construction services the developer provides to you and the sale of the replacement apartment are subject to zero-rate VAT, but only on the portion that does not exceed the value cap (Section 31A(b) of the VAT Law). The portion above the cap is subject to VAT at the standard rate of 18%, so it is advisable to specify in the agreement who bears it. The developer's side, including the deduction of input VAT, is explained on the page VAT in Real Estate Transactions and Urban Renewal.

How Does It Work in Practice?

In practice, the question every apartment owner asks is whether the apartment they receive falls within the cap. The cap is measured by value, so it is worth starting with a common misconception regarding apartment size.

The 25 sqm Rule Belongs to TAMA 38

The condition that the new apartment be no more than 25 sqm larger than the old one is set out in Section 49LG1, which deals with TAMA 38 by way of demolition and reconstruction, and in Section 49LB regarding apartment expansion under TAMA 38 reinforcement. Pinui Binui has no such area limit, and the cap is measured by value according to the three alternatives above.

For example: the owners of a 60 sqm apartment receive a new 100 sqm apartment. Under TAMA 38 demolition and reconstruction, this apartment fails the area test (60 plus 25 is 85 sqm), and the exemption depends on the value alternative in that section. In Pinui Binui, one of the alternatives is the value of a 120 sqm apartment in the same compound, and a 100 sqm apartment in the same project with the same specifications is expected to be worth less. The actual value is determined by an appraiser.

Cash Payment in Addition to the Apartment

Since Amendment 100 to the Law (2023), cash paid by the developer in addition to the apartment is no longer covered by the exemption. The cash, as well as the portion of the apartment's value exceeding the cap, is taxed as the sale of a separate right (Section 49KB(a)(2)). The acquisition value of that portion is a proportionate share of the acquisition value of the old apartment, and its acquisition date is the old apartment's acquisition date (Section 49KG). For an agreement signed before the amendment, it is advisable to check which transitional provisions apply to it.

Rent During the Construction Period

Rent paid by the developer from the demolition of the apartment until you receive possession of the new apartment is tax-exempt. According to Israel Tax Authority Tax Position 04/2025 (July 10, 2025), these payments are not reported as taxable income and no tax is withheld at source from them, even if the old apartment was rented out before the transaction.

When Is the Transaction Considered a Sale?

The date of sale in Pinui Binui is the earliest of three dates: the date on which the condition precedent in the agreement was fulfilled, the date on which the option was exercised, and the date on which the developer began construction on the building (Section 49K). Therefore, the date of sale is not necessarily the date on which the agreement was signed.

The Exemption Defers the Tax

The new apartment takes on the acquisition date and acquisition value of the old apartment (Section 49KG). When you sell it, the capital gain will be calculated from the price and date at which the old apartment was purchased, unless you are entitled to another exemption at that time. According to Israel Tax Authority Tax Position 02/2026 (April 14, 2026), an owner who sells the right to the replacement apartment before its construction is completed is selling a "residential apartment." If it meets the definition of a "qualifying residential apartment," an exemption under Chapter Five-1 or a beneficial linear calculation may be claimed.

When Should You Have Your Case Reviewed?

Before signing the Pinui Binui agreement, while the structure of the consideration can still be changed. These are the situations in which the calculation changes:

  • The developer offers a cash payment in addition to the apartment, for example in lieu of a parking space or storage unit.

  • The new apartment is particularly large or expensive relative to the old one, and it is unclear whether it falls within the cap.

  • You own more than one apartment in the compound, or the apartment is jointly owned with others.

  • The apartment was inherited, or you are considering selling the right to the new apartment before it is built.

  • The agreement does not specify who bears the VAT on the portion above the cap.

Elderly owners and those in need of nursing care have additional tracks under Sections 49KB1 and 49KB2, which allow the replacement apartment to be sold tax-free under certain conditions.

Pinui Binui transactions at the firm are handled by Adv. Ariel Epstein, a partner at the firm, who interned at the Legal Department of the Customs and VAT Division at Israel Tax Authority headquarters.

Questions & Answers

Does the 25 sqm Rule Also Apply in Pinui Binui?
No. The 25 sqm limit is set out in the TAMA 38 arrangements (Sections 49LB and 49LG1). In Pinui Binui, the cap is determined by value, and the highest of the three alternatives in Section 49KB governs, such as the value of a 120 sqm apartment in the same compound.
The developer pays my rent during construction. Do I need to report it to the Income Tax Authority?
No, for the period from the demolition of the apartment until possession of the new apartment is received. This was determined by the Israel Tax Authority in Tax Position 04/2025, and no tax should be withheld at source from the payments either. This holds true even if the old apartment was rented out to others.
Will I Pay Purchase Tax on the New Apartment?
No, if the sale to the developer was made under Section 49KB. Section 49KD exempts the apartment owner from purchase tax on the acquisition of the replacement apartment.
Can I Sell the Right to the New Apartment Before It Is Built?
Yes. According to Tax Position 02/2026, this is the sale of a "residential apartment," and if it meets the conditions of a "qualifying residential apartment," an exemption under Chapter Five-1 or a beneficial linear calculation may be claimed. The acquisition value for calculating the capital gain remains that of the old apartment.
I Own Two Apartments in the Same Building. Does the Exemption Apply to Both?
The exemption is granted on the sale of one or more residential units in the compound (Section 49KB(b)). The condition is that your share of rights in each replacement apartment equals your share of rights in the apartment you sold. The value cap is calculated for each apartment sold.
The information in this article is general information only and does not constitute a substitute for individual legal advice.

Get an Initial Legal Consultation

Leave your details and one of our attorneys will get back to you today.

Call NowWhatsApp