What Happens When Customs Denies Preferential Treatment After the Goods Have Been Released?
Retroactive denial of customs preference occurs when the customs authority in the exporting country verifies a certificate of origin after the goods have already been released in Israel and determines that the certificate is invalid or that the goods are not originating products. Based on that response, Israeli Customs sends the importer a demand notice for the unpaid duty, plus interest and linkage differentials. Under the Indirect Taxes Law (Tax Overpaid or Underpaid), a shortfall on imported goods may be claimed within five years from the date it arose, and in certain cases even later.
Get an Initial Legal Consultation
Leave your details and one of our attorneys will get back to you today.
What the Law Says
The exemption or reduced duty under a trade agreement is conditional on documentation. Section 14(b)(1) of the Customs Tariff, Exemptions and Purchase Tax on Goods Order, 5777-2017, requires a preference document to be submitted no later than the time the import declaration is cleared. A preference document is an EUR1 movement certificate, an exporter's invoice declaration, or a certificate of origin certified by the Jordan Chamber of Commerce and Industry. The rules of origin themselves are explained on the page Rules of Origin and Trade Agreements.
How Long a Preference Document Remains Valid
Since April 29, 2026, validity is determined by the country of origin. A document from EU member states will not be accepted more than 12 months after its date of issue. For the UK, EFTA countries, Turkey and Ukraine the period is 4 months, and for Jordan 6 months. EUR-MED certificates were recognized in a temporary format only until April 30, 2026.
Subsequent Verification
The rules of origin in Protocol 4 to the agreement with the European Union allow the importing country to request verification after release, either at random or where there is reasonable doubt as to the authenticity of the document or the origin of the goods. The verification is carried out by the customs authority of the exporting country, which may require evidence and inspect the exporter's books. If no reply is received within 10 months of the verification request, or the reply is insufficient to determine origin, the importing country denies the preference, except in exceptional circumstances. An identical rule is set out in Protocol B to the agreement with EFTA.
Limitation Period: Five Years, Sometimes Longer
Under Section 1 of the Indirect Taxes Law, the "relevant period" for imported goods is five years from the date the shortfall arose, during which Customs may demand payment (Section 2(a)). Section 2(b) allows a demand even after five years if the shortfall resulted from incorrect information, a false declaration or an incorrect certificate provided by the importer and the importer did not prove good faith, or if the importer knew or should have known of the shortfall.
The Section 3 Exemption
Section 3 of the Law exempts the importer from paying the shortfall only when three conditions are met cumulatively: the shortfall did not result from incorrect information provided by the importer; the importer did not know and should not have known of it; and the importer sold the goods in good faith before the demand, at a price that did not include the shortfall. The Supreme Court held in CA 4814/09 Tempo Beer Industries (December 22, 2010) that the first condition is assessed objectively: the question is whether the information was correct, not what the importer believed about it.
How It Works in Practice
The process begins after the container has already left the port, and often after the goods have been sold. These are the stages:
Release: The goods are released duty-free or at a reduced rate based on the preference document. If doubt arises already at release, they may be released subject to precautionary measures, such as a guarantee, pending a reply.
Verification request: Israeli Customs sends the certificate or a copy of it to the customs authority of the exporting country, together with the reasons for the request.
Verification in the exporting country: The foreign authority contacts the exporter and examines the production and component records. Israeli Customs does not contact the exporter directly.
Demand notice: If the reply denies origin, or no reply is received, the importer is sent a customs demand notice, plus interest and linkage differentials under Section 6A of the Indirect Taxes Law.
Collection: Under Section 4 of the Law, Customs may detain the importer's goods under its supervision until the debt is paid, including goods from a different shipment. In such a situation, the question of release of seized goods also arises.
For example: an importer released machinery from Germany with a customs value of ₪400,000 duty-free, based on an EUR1 certificate. If the general duty rate under the machinery's tariff item is 8%, denial of the preference creates a shortfall of ₪32,000, to which interest and linkage differentials are added.
A judgment of the Rishon LeZion Magistrate's Court dated August 18, 2019, CC 28356-03-15 M. Bruchim & Sons v. State of Israel, shows that there is still room for review even after the certificate has been rejected. The court held that Customs must send the verification request a reasonable time before three years have elapsed from the date of the certificate, since after that date the foreign customs authority is not obliged to respond. It further held that the rejection creates a presumption that the importer provided incorrect information, but the importer may prove origin through other evidence for the purposes of Section 3. The claim was partially accepted: two demand notices were cancelled, and the remainder of the claim was dismissed.
When You Should Have Your Case Reviewed
A demand notice based on origin verification may appear final, but there are situations in which it is worth reviewing it before paying or immediately afterwards:
You received a demand notice but have not seen the foreign customs authority's reply. Request it and check that the import entries listed in it are the same entries as in the notice.
The verification request was sent close to three years after the date of the certificate, or after that date.
The demand arrived more than five years after the import, and Customs relies on Section 2(b).
The overseas supplier has ceased operating or did not respond to the customs authority in its country. In this case, the path to changing the outcome usually runs through the supplier, vis-à-vis that authority.
The goods were sold long ago at a price that did not include duty, and you have evidence of origin beyond the rejected certificate.
Even before any import, make sure the contract with the supplier obliges it to cooperate in verification and to bear the duty if the certificate is rejected.
This area is handled at the firm by Adv. Udi Asa, who worked from 2011 to 2022 in the Legal Department of the Customs and VAT Division at the Israel Tax Authority headquarters.







