What Does a Summons to a Tax Authority Investigation Mean?
A summons to a Tax Authority investigation means that an authorized investigator is requesting to take a statement from you in a criminal proceeding, either as a witness or as a suspect. Investigators act under Section 227 of the Income Tax Ordinance or Section 109 of the Value Added Tax Law, with the powers of a police officer. A person under investigation must answer all questions, except those whose answers might incriminate them. A suspect also has the right to consult with an attorney before the investigation. Whatever you say is recorded in a signed statement and may be used as evidence in an indictment.
Get an Initial Legal Consultation
Leave your details and one of our attorneys will get back to you today.
What the Law Says About Tax Investigations
The law distinguishes between two tracks. The assessing officer who reviews your returns acts under Section 135 of the Income Tax Ordinance, which allows them to demand returns, documents, and information "in order to obtain full knowledge" of the income. This is a civil audit, and when it concludes, an assessment is issued. A criminal investigation is conducted by an assessing officer authorized by the Minister of Police under Section 227 of the Ordinance, and in VAT matters by a person authorized under Section 109 of the Value Added Tax Law.
The Duty to Answer and the Privilege Against Self-Incrimination
The investigator exercises the authority under Section 2 of the Criminal Procedure Ordinance (Testimony). Under Section 2(2), the person being questioned must truthfully answer all questions, except those whose answers might expose them to criminal liability. A witness who is not a suspect answers nearly everything. A suspect may refuse to answer questions that are self-incriminating — this is known as the right to silence. Silence is not an admission, but it does carry weight when the case reaches court, which is why the decision whether to remain silent and to what extent is made before the investigation.
Under Section 3 of the same Ordinance, the statement is recorded, read back to you, and you are asked to sign it. If you refuse to sign, the investigator notes the refusal and the reason given in the margins of the statement.
The Right to Consult an Attorney
Under Section 34 of the Criminal Procedure Law (Enforcement Powers – Arrests), 5756-1996, a detainee is entitled to meet with and consult an attorney, and the officer in charge of the investigation must allow the meeting without delay. A postponement is possible only by a reasoned written decision, for a few hours or at most 24 hours from the time of arrest. In the Yissacharov ruling (CrimA 5121/98), the Supreme Court held in 2006 that a court may exclude a confession obtained without the suspect having been duly informed of the right to consult an attorney. Such exclusion is discretionary and not automatic.
What Penalties Does the Law Prescribe
A willful offense committed with intent to evade tax carries, under Section 220 of the Ordinance, up to seven years' imprisonment, or a fine plus twice the amount of the concealed income. Under the VAT Law, Section 117(b) prescribes up to 5 years' imprisonment, and Section 117(b2) increases the penalty to 7 years in aggravating circumstances. On the other hand, Section 221 of the Ordinance allows the proceedings to be concluded by payment of a monetary compounding amount, with the suspect's consent, in a sum of up to twice the maximum fine.
How It Works in Practice
The process is similar in income tax and VAT cases; what differs is the investigating unit and the statute under which it operates. Details on each track can be found on the pages Representation in Income Tax Investigations and Representation in VAT Investigations.
Before the Investigation
Clarify your status: witness or suspect, and what the suspicion involves. Sometimes this is stated in the summons. If not, you may ask the investigator who summoned you.
Meet with an attorney before the scheduled date, and bring the summons along with any documents related to the matter, such as returns, invoices, and correspondence with your accountant. During the meeting, you will assess what the investigators likely already know and decide in advance what to answer and how.
Do not alter documents, delete files, or coordinate your version of events with employees, partners, or suppliers. Investigators may view such actions as an attempt to obstruct the investigation.
If the date is inconvenient, ask the investigator to postpone it — in writing and as early as possible. The decision rests with the investigating unit.
In the Interrogation Room
A suspect must be informed of the right to consult an attorney at the very start of the investigation. The statement is written during the session and read back to you at its conclusion. Read or listen to it through to the end, and if anything was recorded differently from what you said, request a correction before signing.
After the Investigation
Once the investigation concludes, the case may be closed, referred for prosecution, or brought before the Compounding Committee if an application has been filed. According to the Israel Tax Authority Investigation Division's directive on the processing time for compounding applications, a compounding application is reviewed by the committee within three months of its submission or the conclusion of the investigation, whichever is later. If the committee approves, it sets a period of up to 90 days for payment and any additional conditions, such as paying the outstanding tax debt and filing any unfiled returns. It is possible to request that the compounding amount be spread over up to 6 installments. The directive also applies to offenses under the VAT Law, and further details on these stages can be found on the page Compounding Proceedings and Administrative Penalties.
Common Mistakes Before a Tax Investigation
Most mistakes occur in the days between the summons and the investigation. These are the most frequent:
Treating the summons as a meeting with the assessing officer. In an investigation under Section 227, the statement you give constitutes evidence in criminal proceedings, even if the atmosphere in the room feels relaxed.
Forgoing legal advice so as not to appear guilty. The right to consult an attorney is enshrined in law, and the Supreme Court has held that violating it is a defect that may lead to the exclusion of a confession.
Signing a statement without reviewing it. After signing, it becomes far more difficult to explain why something was recorded differently from what you intended.
Answering some questions and remaining silent on others without having decided on this approach in advance. A decision made under the pressure of the investigation makes it difficult to maintain a consistent line throughout the entire statement.
Income tax and VAT investigations are handled at the firm by Adv. and CPA Shlomi Vaknin, who served for approximately a decade as a national supervisor in the VAT Professional Division of the Israel Tax Authority.
